On What Grounds Can you Challenge a Will?

For what reasons can you challenge a Will?

There are myriad of ways to challenge a Will including but not limited to:

Scrivener’s error - the will has a mistake making it incomprehensible; incomplete; or contradicts itself.

Fraud - can be the altering or forging a Will

Undue Influence - making someone do something they would not others due

Undue influence exists if a person used a position of power over the deceased to “influence” that person to change the Will to benefit the person with the power in a way that the deceased otherwise would not have done.

  • Opportunity; Coercion; Deceit; Deception; Manipulation; Threats; Isolation from Lvoed ones; Control of the testator; False Promises; etc.

  • Who met with the estate attorney to draft the Will?

  • Who communicated with the Estate attorney for the terms of the Will?

  • Who was with decedent when the Will was signed?

  • Did the decedent take himself to attorney to execute the Will?

  • Did they read the Will?

  • Was there Mental and/or Physical Abuse

Lacking Capacity - from illness like dementia or alzheimer’s disease

In order to prove a lack of capacity, there must be evidence of the decedent's mental state, showing that there is evidence that the decedent (testator) lacked one or more of following:

  • Did decedent know the bounty of their estate or what he owned or possessed

  • Did they know the precise nature and provisions of the will

  • Did they know the nature, extent, and condition of his or her assets and property

  • Did the decedent know who were the individuals who ordinarily would inherit his or her estate

    *evidence about a person’s memory decline or impairment, lack of comprehension and judgment, and inability to communicate constitute circumstantial evidence to help prove the claims.

Diminished Capacity with undue influence - the greater the decedent’s impairment the less undue influence is needed to prove undue influence.

Mistake in fact - such as thinking some had passed away or they had taken care of other loved ones by other mans.

Formalities of executing a Will were not followed:

  • There needs to have been two signatory witnesses on the Will itself unless it is a holographic Will (entirely handwritten Will)

  • The Will has to show testamentary intent

  • The Will needs to have been signed by the Testator and witnessed

  • The Will has to be the original document albeit there are exceptions

  • The Will cannot have been revoked by Testator

  • The Will can not have been altered or changed after execution

    Does a Will need to be notarized?

  • No

    Can you probate a copy of Will?

  • It depends, consult your estate attorney

    Can you probate a handwritten Will (holographic Will)?

  • Yes